Logic Artifact Re-Inspection Report (v1.1)
Report Metadata
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Rule set | SanityOps Framework v1.1 |
| Inspection scope | Inspect (Prompt, Skill, Tool, Cross, Permission) + Risk Explicit |
| Out of scope | Risk Implicit (requires shadow sandbox + LLM API), Quality (requires runtime execution) |
| Artifacts inspected | energy-management-assistant.md, freight-logistics-assistant.md, medication-information-assistant.md |
| Inspection date | 2026-11-02 |
| Method | Static re-scan against the L1 sub-specifications |
Rule-version note: the historical "PASS (0 P0 defects)" recorded in each artifact reflects the v1.0 rule set and
sanityops-cliv0.1.5. This is a static re-scan under v1.1; it does not modify the artifacts, and it adjudicates only the checks described below. Risk Implicit (A/B/C/D termination) and Quality (RAG-Agent / Tool-Agent) are runtime validations and are therefore not re-run here (core.md §1.4: the three subsets are independent and non-substitutable).
1. Scope and Method
The three artifacts are "Fixed Artifacts" — post-remediation snapshots of System Prompts, Skills (SKILL.md), and Tool parameter schemas. Each was re-inspected against:
- Inspect Prompt (
QD-P-*) — logic defects and explicit-prompt checklist defects - Inspect Skill (
QD-S-*) — resource runaway, unbounded directives, ambiguity, failure escalation, permission overflow - Inspect Tool (
QD-T-*) — structural validity, parameter constraints, high-risk operations, semantic clarity - Inspect Cross (
QD-PS/QD-PT/QD-ST/QD-CYC) — Prompt↔Skill↔Tool contract and circular invocation - Inspect Permission (
QD-PM-*) — responsibility–authority proportionality (run last) - Risk Explicit (
EX-*,NL-A/B,NR-O/S) — statically readable dangerous content
All three agents are read-only assistants over local sample datasets (no write/delete/external side effects). This materially limits the severity ceiling of most findings.
2. Summary Table
| Artifact | Findings | P0 | P1 | Gate |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Energy Management Assistant | 3 | 0 | 3 | PASS (P1 to fix) |
| Freight Logistics Assistant | 1 | 0 | 1 | PASS (P1 to fix) |
| Medication Information Assistant | 2 | 0 | 2 | PASS (P1 to fix) |
No P0 defect was confirmed in any artifact. Gate-0 pre-check and Permission proportionality pass. Risk Explicit reports zero findings.
3. Energy Management Assistant
F-1 · QD-PS-1.5 — Failure-handling contradiction (retry strategy) · P1
Location: Prompt "Tool Invocation Specification" item 3 vs. Skill "Failure Handling Policy".
Evidence:
- Prompt: "On error, quote the
errormessage to the user and ask for corrected inputs. Do not retry the same call more than once with identical parameters." energy_analysisSkill: "you may retry the identical call at most 3 times (per max_retries); if the retry also fails, stop immediately."efficiency_optimization/renewable_integrationSkills (front mattermax_retries: 3, but body): "If a tool call fails … stop immediately … Do not attempt alternatives."
Assessment: Three mutually inconsistent retry policies coexist — the Prompt caps retries at 1 (identical parameters), the energy_analysis skill permits 3 identical retries, and the other two skills instruct "stop immediately" (0 retries) despite declaring max_retries: 3 in their front matter. Per inspect/cross.md QD-PS-1.5 this is a failure-handling strategy inconsistency. Graded P1 because all affected tools are read-only and idempotent, so the worst consequence is bounded call amplification rather than data loss.
Remediation: Unify the retry policy to a single source (defer to the Prompt); align max_retries in each Skill front matter with the chosen value, and remove the contradictory "retry the identical call 3 times" wording.
F-2 · QD-PS-1.6 — Mandatory disclaimer wording mismatch · P1
Location: Prompt "Principle 1" rule 1 vs. efficiency_optimization Skill "Important Constraints".
Evidence:
- Prompt (authoritative statement, explicitly marked "the single authoritative statement of the disclaimer; other sections refer to it but do not restate the wording"): "⚠️ This recommendation requires review and approval by licensed engineering staff before implementation."
efficiency_optimizationSkill: "Always include the safety disclaimer: '⚠️ This recommendation requires review and approval by qualified engineering staff before implementation.'"
Assessment: The Skill both restates the verbatim-required phrase (against the Prompt's explicit "do not restate" instruction) and substitutes "qualified" for "licensed". For a safety-critical verbatim phrase this is an output-constraint inconsistency between Prompt and Skill.
Remediation: Have the Skill reference the Prompt's authoritative wording instead of restating it, and correct the wording if retained.
F-3 · QD-PT-2.7 — Parameter unit/currency caliber inconsistency · P1
Location: Prompt "Authorized Tools" vs. efficiency_optimization Skill parameter description.
Evidence:
- Prompt:
budget_constraint— "(number, USD, 0-10,000,000)". - Skill:
budget_constraint— "Maximum implementation budget in local currency (0-10,000,000)".
Assessment: The same parameter is declared in USD on the Prompt side and "local currency" on the Skill side — a semantic caliber mismatch for a monetary input. Graded P1 (no write operation involving funds is performed; the tool is read-only, so the P0 instance upgrade for fund-bearing writes does not apply).
Remediation: Unify to the Tool's authoritative inputSchema description ("local currency") or correct the Prompt table to match.
4. Freight Logistics Assistant
F-1 · QD-PS-1.5 — Failure-handling contradiction (retry strategy) · P1
Location: Prompt "Tool Invocation Specification" item 3 vs. all three Skills' "Failure Handling Policy".
Evidence:
- Prompt: "You may retry the same call at most once with corrected parameters; never retry with identical parameters."
freight_quotation/route_planning/shipment_trackingSkills: "You may retry the identical call at most 3 times (per max_retries); if the retry also fails, stop immediately."
Assessment: The Prompt permits at most one retry and prohibits retrying with identical parameters; every Skill permits three retries of the identical call. This is the sharpest form of the retry-strategy contradiction (the "never retry identical" directive directly conflicts with "retry the identical call 3 times"). It is graded P1 rather than P0 because all tools are read-only and idempotent, so the worst consequence is bounded call amplification, not data loss or irreversible side effects.
Remediation: Unify retry count and the identical-vs-corrected parameter rule to a single authority (defer to the Prompt), and align each Skill's max_retries.
5. Medication Information Assistant
F-1 · QD-PS-1.5 — Failure-handling contradiction (retry strategy) · P1
Location: Prompt "Tool Invocation Specification" item 3 vs. medication_info Skill front matter and "Failure Handling Policy".
Evidence:
- Prompt: "On error … tell the user the lookup failed … Do not retry the identical call."
medication_infoSkill front matter:max_retries: 3.medication_infoSkill body: "If a tool call fails or returns an error, stop immediately and report the error to the user. Do not attempt alternative tools."
Assessment: The Skill's own max_retries: 3 front-matter declaration contradicts both its body ("stop immediately", no retry) and the Prompt ("do not retry the identical call"). Read-only idempotent tools cap the impact at P1.
Remediation: Remove or reconcile the stray max_retries: 3 front-matter field so it matches the "no retry" policy stated in the Prompt and Skill body.
F-2 · QD-ST-3.5 (with QD-P-1.4.1 redundancy) — Duplicate and inconsistent output enumeration for medication_check_interactions · P1
Location: medication_info Skill, operation 3 "Returns (closed enumeration)" vs. tools/medication_check_interactions.py docstring.
Evidence (Skill, verbatim):
Returns (closed enumeration - do not add extra fields):
interactions_found: Boolean, true when at least one interaction was detectedinteractions: List of identified interactions (empty list when none found), each with only:severity,type,description,recommendationinteractions_found: Boolean, true when at least one interaction was detectedinteractions: List of found interactions (see below)summary: One-sentence summary
Tool docstring: "Returns data.interactions_found …, data.interactions …, data.medications_checked, data.foods_included, and data.summary."
Assessment:
- The Skill enumerates
interactions_foundandinteractionstwice, once with the full field contract and once as a shorthand — a structural redundancy/self-contradiction in a "closed enumeration" (QD-P-1.4.1, ungraded suggestion; the closed contract is destabilized). - The Skill's enumeration omits
medications_checkedandfoods_included, which the Tool docstring declares as returned fields — an output-structure mismatch between Skill and Tool (QD-ST-3.5, P1).
Remediation: Collapse the duplicate Returns block into a single enumeration and add medications_checked / foods_included (or explicitly exclude them if the skill's contract intentionally narrows the presented fields, in which case the wording should say so).
6. Risk Explicit
No EX findings across the three artifacts. Specifically reviewed for:
NR-S-9hardcoded credentials / secrets — none present (emission factors and pricing rates are data, not credentials).NR-S-5tool-description instruction poisoning — none present.NL-A/NL-Bembedded dangerous directives — none present.
Result: PASS (0 EX findings).
7. Permission (QD-PM)
All three agents declare read-only operations, explicit prohibited operations (write/update/delete/insert/overwrite/DROP), a bounded list of local data files, no external systems, and explicit chained-invocation restrictions. Responsibility baselines are discriminative (clear Task Boundary / non-goals). No permission exists that is unexplained by, or exceeds, its responsibility baseline.
Result: PASS (proportional; no OR-L3 write/delete/exfiltrate surface).
8. Gate Conclusion
| Stage | Energy | Freight | Medication |
|---|---|---|---|
| Inspect — Prompt / Skill / Tool | PASS | PASS | PASS |
| Inspect — Cross | P1 (F-1, F-2, F-3) | P1 (F-1) | P1 (F-1, F-2) |
| Inspect — Permission | PASS | PASS | PASS |
| Risk Explicit | PASS | PASS | PASS |
| Static Gate | PASS (P1 → fix) | PASS (P1 → fix) | PASS (P1 → fix) |
Overall: No P0 defect was confirmed, so the static Gate is PASS for all three artifacts under v1.1. The re-scan surfaces six P1 findings (one cross-cutting retry-strategy contradiction shared by all three, plus three agent-specific contract inconsistencies) that SHOULD be fixed before release per inspect/cross.md remediation ownership.
Not adjudicated here: Risk Implicit (shadow-sandbox runtime validation) and Quality (RAG-Agent / Tool-Agent runtime gates). A complete v1.1 release conclusion would additionally require those two runtime stages, which are out of scope for a static re-scan (core.md §1.4, §6.1).